Skip to main content
← Back to articles

Livonia City Council passes 2027 budget, 6-1

LIVONIA — 11/1/2026

The Livonia City Council adopted a fiscal 2027 budget 6-1 on Oct. 26, passed a sidewalk waiver on Fairlane Avenue that failed on a tie Oct. 12, and approved a lawsuit settlement after a closed session. Council Member Brandon McCullough cast the only vote against the budget, and Council President Kayleigh Reid called the vote over his objection when he asked to respond to colleagues who had criticized him.

All seven members attended the 2051st regular meeting at the City Hall Auditorium, 33000 Civic Center Drive. Council Member Eileen McDonnell returned after missing the Oct. 5 and Oct. 12 meetings. No item was denied.

Significant events

Budget passes after debate over capital spending

Council Member Martha Ptashnik, who chairs the Finance and Budget Committee, moved to approve the budget "with the changes presented to us on October 22nd by the administration," and McDonnell supported. The changes are in an Oct. 22 memo from Finance Director Benjamin Grier, attached to the budget item as "Additional Information Item Adjustment to FY 2027 Budget." They were not read into the record at the meeting. The figures below are the memo's revised ones where it changes them. The rest come from the preliminary budget dated Sept. 15, its personnel supplement, the 2026 assessment data book and the administration's budget presentation.

Grier told the council Oct. 5 that the changes would be "only relatively minor adjustments" and that "a few more items" could still change. Those he named then were corrections to the mayor's salary, to $144,954, and the clerk's salary, and moving police vehicle funding to the capital projects fund. The personnel supplement, which predates the memo, lists the mayor at $156,215 and the clerk at $103,271. The current budget lists them at $144,954 and $107,243.

  • All funds: $235,988,795 in spending under the memo, up $1,031,202 from the $234,957,593 in the preliminary budget. The Sept. 21 committee minutes say $235 million across 34 funds. Grier told the council Oct. 5 it was "just under 239 million."
  • General Fund: revenue of $77,675,021 and expenses of $77,672,569, a surplus of $2,452. The preliminary budget had $77,839,036 and $77,836,584, with the same surplus. The projected fund balance is $19,389,964 on Nov. 30, 2027, about 25% of annual spending. The budget presentation put staffing and personnel at $62.3 million, or 80.1%. Police are budgeted at $30,117,263 and fire at $18,676,487, both unchanged by the memo.
  • Tax rate: 13.6841 mills in the preliminary budget, down 0.0293 from 13.7134 under the Headlee Amendment. The memo corrects errors in calculating the Headlee rollback and does not state a revised rate. The budget document ranks that second lowest in Wayne County. The assessment data book's 2025 rates support that ranking among cities: Plymouth at 13.6964, Livonia at 13.7134. The book's township table lists six Wayne County townships with lower 2025 rates, from Plymouth Township at 5.1248 to Canton Township at 12.2721.
  • Tax bill: the Sept. 21 Finance and Budget Committee notes say the average homeowner pays $1,404 a year to the city. Grier told the council Oct. 5 that a typical homeowner pays about $4,500 in property tax, with $1,450 going to the city. The data book's average taxable value for an improved residential parcel, $110,578, works out to about $1,513 at 13.6841 mills.
  • Tax base: taxable value of $5,818,493,398, up 4.12% from 2025, and state equalized value of $7,963,274,660, up 6.33%, according to the data book. It estimates the average improved residential true cash value at $319,414, up from $301,980. The Sept. 21 committee notes give an "overall taxable value increase" of 6.41%; the data book shows 6.41% as the rise in real property state equalized value.
  • Staffing: 656 funded positions, 624 full-time and 32 part-time, the same total as the current budget, and a 4.5% cost-of-living increase. Police stay at 193 positions and fire at 94. The personnel supplement adds a position each at 16th District Court and equipment maintenance, and removes one each in water and sewer and cable TV. Cable TV staff drops from four to three "due to lack of funding," with a $155,000 subsidy. The memo gives no revised position count.
  • Capital: a $2.4 million transfer of Medicare Advantage savings to the Building Improvement Fund (Fund 418) and $6.811 million in projects from it, including $1.5 million to demolish the old courthouse and senior center. Fund 418 is budgeted to take in $2.77 million, and its balance is projected to reach $4,653,448 by Nov. 30, 2027, down from $10,730,171 on Nov. 30, 2025.
  • Roads: a $15.27 million road program.
  • Revenue: state shared revenue is down $866,000.
  • Start date: the fiscal year begins Dec. 1, 2026.

The memo made these changes. Grier wrote that the total effect on the General Fund is neutral.

  • General Fund revenue: property tax revenue drops $164,015, to $45,773,256, because it was overstated by errors in calculating Headlee rollback adjustments.
  • General Fund cuts: termination pay, $114,919, after a review of the city's liability and past experience; leased engineering equipment, $34,661, an input error; election contractual services, $25,000, because higher pay for election workers is not expected to be needed; 16th District Court, $24,429, after a decision not to budget a part-time violations clerk; the mayor's department, $13,629, an input error; and finance, $11,747, because the capital planning and budget manager was budgeted a step too high.
  • General Fund additions: inspection, $33,344, and the clerk's department, $5,026, both input errors; accounting, $19,000, mostly for outside help "amid ongoing staffing challenges"; and finance, $3,000, for budget assistance.
  • Capital Projects Fund: spending rises $1,549,173, to $4,472,373. That includes $700,173 for LED streetlight replacement, with $616,300 in grants from the Southeast Michigan Council of Governments and DTE; $399,000 for patrol cars, added "due to an oversight"; and $450,000 for police vehicles, moved from the Adjudicated Forfeiture Fund. The memo calls all of it unmarked vehicles; the preliminary capital list shows $330,000 for six unmarked and $120,000 for two marked. The fund's balance is projected at $42,989 on Nov. 30, 2027, down from $8,798,316 on Nov. 30, 2025.
  • Transit and Capital Improvements Fund: revenue rises $96,044 to correct a carried-forward figure, and the money passes to the Capital Projects Fund.
  • Other property tax corrections: revenue drops $18,858 in the Roads, Sidewalk and Tree Fund, $16,327 in Community Recreation and $17,911 in the Library Fund. Their projected Nov. 30, 2027, balances are $134,311, $922,351 and $3,050,360.

The total for the capital plan differs within the budget documents, all of which predate the memo. The budget presentation gives $42,945,450 in its capital table and $42,321,000 as the recommended funding on the same slide. The capital list in the budget book gives $43,318,250. The memo gives no revised total for the plan. The budget document says the administration has identified more than $125 million in facility needs citywide over the next 10 years. Speaking about City Hall, McCullough cited $40 million from the facility needs assessment.

McCullough's objection

McCullough said of $6.8 million in planned building improvements that "we haven't seen this much of an investment, which is what we do need," then read out the line items and said he had "huge red flags." "I'm not trying to say no to the budget, because I want to shut down the government," he said. "It's going to pass today, but I think it's finally time to stand up and say, listen, it's not working and we need to do better."

The fund's project list totals $6,811,000. The figures McCullough read match the budget's project list. He did not read the Fox Creek item.

AreaItems he readBudget total
FireStorage pole barn, $250,000; security cameras for five stations, $100,000; Fire Station 3 roof, $525,000; Fire Station 3 infrared heaters, $51,000$926,000
PoliceAir handlers, $750,000; boilers, $300,000; gun range and storage roofs, about $100,000$1,150,000
City Hall and annexVAV control system, $400,000; fountain, $250,000; annex rooftop unit, $250,000; annex boilers and pumps, $225,000; basement encapsulation, $160,000; mini-split, $140,000; clerk's area VAV, $35,000; sump pumps, $20,000$1,480,000
Public works and arenaEddie Edgar Ice Arena roof, $750,000; fleet maintenance roof, $450,000; fleet heaters, $185,000; building 12 HVAC, $220,000; building 12 boilers, $75,000$1,680,000
GolfFox Creek clubhouse HVAC, not read$75,000
DemolitionDemolition and abatement of the old senior center and courthouse, $1.5 million$1,500,000

McCullough, who said facilities work is his career, called the annex items "redundancy times a million": boilers, a mini-split and a rooftop unit serving the same building. No council member addressed that claim specifically. He said the demolition has "no real mechanism of what is going to happen there after."

He then listed places with no named capital funding, including the Alfred Noble and Carl Sandburg libraries, Greenmead Historical Park, four fire stations apart from security cameras, and the three senior housing sites. He said some work could fall under general building maintenance. The capital list recommends $131,250 for Sandburg, for books, computers and chairs. He said only three of the city's 60 parks are named for capital work. The budget presentation lists Mies Path and Botsford at $50,000 each and Clements Circle at $15,000. The budget's detailed capital list recommends $26,000 for Botsford and $121,000 for Clements Circle.

The response

Council Member Carrie Budzinski said the list "isn't wholly accurate," and that projects get a second vote once bids are in. "This is a living document," she said. She said that, working with colleagues, she got a capital improvement manager position funded and, using Community Development Block Grant funds, a new Hillcrest playground. She said she called McCullough to offer support after what she called the Sept. 21 public hearing, and that he answered, "I'm out. I'm a no. Do what you want." The packet lists Sept. 21 as the committee meeting and Oct. 5 as the hearing.

Council Member Robin Persiconi said the projects "need to happen" and had been deferred while the 2025 facilities proposal was pending, and said that proposal failed. "We went through this budget with a magnifying glass," she said.

Ptashnik spoke a second time and addressed McCullough's opposition. She said he offered no "single alternative, a single amendment or a single fundamental reason," and that opposing a budget "simply for the sake of opposition" is "an abdication of your basic responsibility as a council member." She said a failed budget would make city operations "grind to a halt," and that the budget "should not be used to create chaos and division so that someone can try and position themselves as a political hero." She also referred to "social media temper tantrums." McCullough had said people could "sit here and grandstand" that he has political ambitions.

Vice President Patrick Brockway said the budget "keeps the lights on" and noted that Zoom access was included. McDonnell said she understood McCullough's concerns and had some of her own, naming the City Hall entrance ramp and accessible bathrooms as items she thought belonged on the capital list, and would vote yes because a budget had to pass. Offered the floor, Mayor Maureen Miller Brosnan let the audience go first and said her team was present for questions.

Where the accounts differ

  • Whether he raised it. Budzinski said McCullough never specifically stated an objection to the capital list during the process. McCullough said he asked for backup on the $6.8 million and was told none would be provided. In minutes of the Oct. 5 hearing, he cited "6 million plus building improvements with no detailed backup," questioned the $750,000 Eddie Edgar roof and said he would offer a motion to deny the budget. Budzinski answered him that night on "what Mr. McCullough mentioned in terms of the budgeted amounts." No amendment was offered on Oct. 26.
  • Access to the administration. Ptashnik said "at least the six of us" met with the finance department and administration. McCullough said Oct. 5 that he had emailed the administration asking to discuss the Noble library and got "nothing, silence."
  • What a yes vote does. Ptashnik and Budzinski said the budget approves no project. Budzinski said Oct. 5 that "the budget saves the space for certain projects or proposals. It does not spend the money." McCullough said that night that "it's just a budget" also described nearly $1 million for the Rotary Pavilion, "until we stopped it."
  • Parks. McCullough named Shelden and Hillcrest parks among those with no capital item. Budzinski said there is a bond for Shelden and that Hillcrest is in the budget. The budget presentation's debt table lists a 2026 capital improvement bond for Shelden Park with a $4.88 million balance as of Dec. 1, 2026, and the personnel supplement says the park is expected to be under construction during fiscal 2026, with its pool converted to a splash pad. Budzinski described the Hillcrest playground as funded last year with Community Development Block Grant money; the 2027 capital list in the packet does not name it. Persiconi said Rotary and Bicentennial parks were recently improved.
  • Senior housing. McCullough listed McNamara Towers, Newburgh Village and Silver Village as having nothing named, and noted a $150,000 housing line with no breakdown. Persiconi said McNamara is federally funded and that the Livonia Housing Commission handles the other two. The budget's capital list names $94,000 for stoves at Newburgh Village and $150,000 at Silver Village for bathtub conversions and tuck-pointing.
  • The capital manager. Budzinski said she and colleagues secured a funded capital improvement manager position. Resident Cindy Fleming said it was never filled and that two part-time jobs were combined instead. McCullough said a facilities manager approved "two budgets ago" is "still not there." The personnel supplement shows a capital planning manager and a budget manager combined into one job, split between the General Fund and water and sewer, and lists both earlier jobs as full-time. A note in the budget's staffing pages says the capital improvement program director position was reclassed as capital planning and budget manager and moved to finance.
  • Staff and pay. McCullough said people at the base are at minimum wage while "people at the top" get raises. Persiconi said the raises go to "the 700 employees"; the budget lists 656 funded positions and a 4.5% cost-of-living increase. Grier told the council Oct. 5 that with an unbudgeted 3.5% cost-of-living adjustment and 2.2% wage adjustments, "there's a 10% across the board increase in salaries."

Six people spoke on the budget, and none spoke in favor. Their comments are in the public comment timeline below.

Reid calls the vote; McCullough objects

Reid called the vote over McCullough's objection after he said he had a right to speak and had a rebuttal. City Attorney Eric Goldstein said the decision was at the president's discretion.

Times are from the meeting video.
TimeWhat happened
51:57Ptashnik speaks in favor for about a minute.
53:11McCullough speaks for about six minutes and says he will vote no.
59:05Budzinski answers him for about five minutes.
1:04:22Persiconi speaks for about four minutes and answers points he raised.
1:08:41Reid asks, "Did you have something more?" Ptashnik speaks for about two more minutes.
1:10:48Brockway and McDonnell speak.
1:13:02Reid: "Since everyone up here got a chance to speak, I'm going to go to audience communication." A voice the transcript does not identify says, "May I speak." Reid: "I'm going to go to the audience first." Six members of the public follow.
1:25:46Reid: "We're gonna go to the vote now. Mr. McCullough, I see your hand." She adds, "I have discretion on this."
1:26:05McCullough: "I'm a council member. The charter states I can speak on this item." He says he has a rebuttal.
1:26:12Reid: "I don't think it's going to change anyone's vote up here. Let's move along."
1:26:17McCullough: "You're scared to let me speak?" Reid: "I'm not scared of you whatsoever. I want to move the meeting along."
1:26:28McCullough says it is his right and points out that Ptashnik spoke twice. Reid turns to Goldstein.
1:26:36Goldstein: "It is at the discretion of the president to run the meeting. Everyone has already spoken. So the box is checked."
1:26:47McCullough raises a point of information and asks whether a council majority could allow him to speak. The transcript then has "The Council president does not have that right. Right," with no speaker identified. Reid asks the clerk to take the vote, and he raises further points of information.
1:27:05Reid: "We already heard what you had to say." The transcript, which has no speaker labels, then has "The dictator of council." Reid: "I'm not saying I am, but I am the president." She adds, "I'm the chair of this meeting," "We've heard enough from you" and "Do not speak to me in that language."
1:27:26The roll is called. The budget passes 6-1.

McCullough raised a point of order and points of information. The meeting transcript, which has overlapping speech and no speaker labels, shows no motion on the floor to let him speak before the roll call.

What the rules say

Neither McCullough nor Goldstein cited a section at the meeting. The charter, in Chapter IV, Section 6, says, "The President shall preside over the meetings of the Council and shall be entitled to vote." Section 10 says, "The Council shall determine its own rules." Section 9 says the council may, "by a majority vote of those present," compel attendance and "enforce orderly conduct." The charter's text does not mention how often or how long a member may speak.

A note in the charter says the council's rules are in Chapter 2.04 of the city code. The part of that chapter posted on the City Council's web page, 2.04.050(C), limits members of the public to two minutes on an agenda item and three minutes in audience communication.

Oct. 5

Minutes of the Oct. 5 budget hearing, which Reid also chaired, show McCullough speaking twice. He first listed his objections. After colleagues responded, Reid called on him again: "Thank you. Mr. McCullough?" He began that turn, "You know it's easy to make statements." Ptashnik also took several turns that night, and no vote was pending; the hearing sent the budget on to Oct. 26.

Afterward

At second audience communication, Denise Mika said one council member "got to speak twice, which was a rebuttal on what somebody else said," and that "the other council person should have had a chance as a rebuttal, because I don't think that was fair."

McCullough then said he was recusing himself, and spoke to Reid as a resident during audience communication. "What we've seen today is an embarrassment," he said. He apologized "for my emotional stance" and said "everything that was brought up was orchestrated." He said he will have his chance at the next meeting and referred to "some immature battle." He said there are comments that he cannot work with his colleagues and that "if you want receipts, we'll show the receipts."

"Things aren't working," he said, adding that next year's election will bring a new mayor and up to four new council members.

Fairlane Avenue sidewalk waiver passes

The request from builder Angelo Mauti covers four new homes at 15235, 15251, 15273 and 15287 Fairlane Avenue. On Oct. 12 it failed 3-3, with McCullough, Ptashnik and Brockway in favor and Budzinski, Persiconi and Reid opposed. An earlier resolution, #125-24, had denied a waiver on April 1, 2024.

McDonnell tried to revive it during council announcements. Goldstein said she lacked standing because she had been absent, and that he thought a member who voted no could bring it back, because a tie left no clear prevailing side. Budzinski did so. The motion to reconsider passed 5-2, and the waiver then passed 5-2, with Persiconi and Reid opposed both times.

Accounts differed on two points:

  • The notice. Mauti said the 2024 denial letter went to the prior owner and that he did not know about it. Persiconi said it was "mailed to the right address."
  • The plan date. Persiconi said the plat with sidewalks was approved in 2024. City Engineer Todd Zilincik said the plan showing sidewalks was approved "in April of 26."

Persiconi gave this timeline: waiver requested Aug. 31, 2026; engineering permit Sept. 22; concrete poured Sept. 23; council vote Oct. 12. Zilincik said he wrote his recommendation Sept. 10, favored the sidewalk because of pedestrian safety near Five Mile Road, and checked only concrete thickness when inspecting the approach. "He gambled," Zilincik said. Mauti said engineering inspected and approved the pour. Brockway said the city has no plans for sidewalks in the area, and the resolution text cites no sidewalk on the 11 adjacent lots.

Closed session and settlement

The council voted 7-0 by roll call, with two-thirds required, to meet in closed session on Frank D. Robinson v City of Livonia, et al., Wayne County Circuit Court No. 24-012254-NI. Reid said the Law Department needed an answer before the next meeting and called the mid-meeting session "a first for me." Members were briefed upstairs by the Law Department and outside counsel. On returning, they approved "the settlement presented to us from the law Department" 7-0. The amount was not stated.

Tribute to former Mayor Jack Kirksey

Reid read a tribute to Jack E. Kirksey, whose death the Detroit Free Press reported Oct. 14, at age 97. It cited his 16 years as mayor and service as state representative, 16th District Court probation director, Schoolcraft College trustee, Livonia Public Schools teacher and administrator, and retired U.S. Air Force lieutenant colonel. It credited him with the Jack E. Kirksey Recreation Center, the Fallen Heroes Memorial and a new 16th District Court. The council held a moment of silence. Reid said the tribute will be presented to his family at a memorial.

Ptashnik said Kirksey's state representative race was the first campaign she worked on and that he later spoke on distracted driving at Churchill High School, where she taught. McCullough said his legacy "will live on." Reid, whose father was city attorney during his tenure, recalled the Stanley Cup in the mayor's office.

Madonna University softball recognized

The council honored Madonna University's softball team, the 2026 NAIA national champions. It was the first national title in program history, capping a 52-win season with an 8-4 win over Southeastern University on May 28. The certificate read at the meeting placed the game in Columbus, Ohio. The NAIA lists the finals site as Columbus, Georgia.

Agenda actions

ItemDescriptionOutcome
Denied
NoneNo item was denied Oct. 26. The Fairlane Avenue sidewalk waiver, which failed on a 3-3 tie Oct. 12, passed on reconsideration.None
Minutes and added motions
Oct. 12 minutesPtashnik corrected the minutes, which had reversed two statements: residents spoke during audience communication, and none spoke on the item listed.Approved as corrected, 7-0
Sidewalk waiver, reconsiderationBrings back the failed Oct. 12 waiver for 15235, 15251, 15273 and 15287 Fairlane Avenue, NW ¼ of Section 21.Approved, 5-2
Sidewalk waiverWaives sidewalks for Angelo Mauti's four new homes, against the City Engineer's recommendation. The Oct. 12 resolution text reserves the city's right to require sidewalks if others are later installed nearby.Approved, 5-2
Infrastructure referralRefers long-term infrastructure investment and planning to the Capital Outlay and Infrastructure Committee. Budzinski, citing the audience's comments, first proposed the Economic Development and Strategic Planning Committee and changed the motion. McCullough voted yes and said it would be "a placeholder and, uh, more talk."Approved, 7-0
Reports received and filed (no vote)
Purchases reportMonth ending Sept. 30, including ElectionSource, $15,023.50, and Clarke Mosquito Control, $19,650.40.Filed
Financial statementsThrough June 30: General Fund revenue of $61.85 million of $76.98 million (80%) and expenses of $36.38 million, plus $1.15 million encumbered, of $77.55 million amended (48%).Filed
Investment reportQuarter ending May 31: certificates of deposit $39,000,000; pooled cash $95,389,802.03; securities $34,507,649.33.Filed
Consent agenda (one vote, 7-0)
1. Infinity Homes & Co., Petition 2026-07-02-21Planned residential development of seven attached ranch condominiums at 28001 Seven Mile Road and two single-family homes at 19021 and 19017 Floral Street, the former Up North Craft Bar site. The Planning Commission recommended approval unanimously (#09-57-2026). Conditions include approval strictly as condominiums rather than apartments, offering each unit for sale for at least six months after its certificate of occupancy, stone and Hardie board on the condos, added sidewalks and a one-year approval. Petitioner's representative Rob Donovic estimated condos at about $270,000-$290,000 and homes at about $350,000-$360,000. The resolution recites a July 14 hearing; the Planning Commission minutes show Sept. 1.Approved
2. Afor Concepts, Petition 2026-08-02-23Brome Modern Eatery at 19450 Haggerty Road, the former PNC Bank, with 64 indoor and 40 patio seats. The Planning Commission recommended approval (#09-63-2026), with Caramagno opposed and Long absent. Its 13 conditions bar an LED light band, move the trash enclosure to the east side of the building, send the canopy infill building back to the Planning Commission for review and require its construction to start before any certificate of occupancy. The packet differs on details: the ordinance section is 6.52 in the agenda item and 6.51 in the resolution; the resolution recites a July 14 hearing, while the staff report shows Sept. 22, and its text omits the words approving the petition subject to the conditions; staff counts 56 required and provided parking spaces, while the plan sheet lists 47 required and provided and refers to 53 shown; staff counts 64 indoor seats, while the plan sheet lists 51.Approved
3. EGLE conservation easementUpdated easement along a branch of Bell Creek in Fox Creek Golf Course, reduced to 2.52 acres. NorthPoint Development (permittee NP Lordstown 173, LLC) provides off-site stream mitigation at no city cost, with five years of monitoring. The original size is 3.37 acres in the Parks letter and 3.47 acres in the survey.Approved
4. Residential Cross Connection Control ProgramReferral only of a five-year contract under what the DPW letter calls an unfunded state mandate. The city has about 36,660 residential connections. The scope calls for 7,000 inspections in year one and at least 3,300 a year after. No contract was awarded. The agenda sends it to the Capital Outlay Committee; the DPW letter says the Infrastructure Committee.Referred to committee
5. Brush chipper2027 Bandit 15XP, $56,644.85, from ALTA Equipment, 13211 Merriman Road, through MiDEAL. Account 226-528-987-000.Approved
6. Fleet repair vendorsSixteen outside vendors, not to exceed $250,000 in fiscal 2027. Account 101-443-933-050.Approved
Unfinished business: committees
7a. Fiscal 2027 budgetBudget and millage for the year ending Nov. 30, 2027, from the Sept. 21 Finance and Budget Committee meeting; public hearing Oct. 5.Approved with Oct. 22 changes, 6-1
8a. Seven Mile/Farmington Venture, LPPetition 2023-06-02-07, CR 284-24, CR 321-26. Schostak Brothers & Company, for the venture, seeks to extend the residential construction deadline from Dec. 31, 2026, to Dec. 31, 2027, citing construction costs, inflation and interest rates. The agreement provides for $5,000 a month in liquidated damages. The council asked for a realistic plan and timeline to clean up the site, including fencing and pavement.Remains in Committee of the Whole; no vote
8b. Wonderland Flats consent judgmentCR 320-26. Melissa Wojnar-Raycraft of The Mike Cox Law Firm, for developer Middlebelt Plymouth Ventures, seeks more time to apply for permits, citing economic conditions. A car wash parcel was sold to a bank, and the council is to receive a revised judgment removing that language. Members also asked the Assistant City Attorney whether the judgment requires approval and what follows a denial or no action.Remains in Committee of the Whole; no vote
Unfinished business: Department of Public Works
9. Case 580SN backhoe$162,029.95 from Southeastern Equipment, Novi, including a $4,950 warranty and $17,100 claw. Account 401-000-987-000. The agenda says MiDEAL; the DPW letter says Sourcewell contract 011723-CNH. Held from an earlier consent agenda so McDonnell could get answers.Approved, 7-0
10. Leaf vacuumsTwo Titan-Pro trailer-mounted units at $92,541 each, $185,082 total, from Bell Equipment, Lake Orion, through MiDEAL 071B7700091. Account 226-528-987-000. Held for the same reason.Approved, 7-0
New business: Department of Law
11. Closed Committee of the WholeFrank D. Robinson v City of Livonia, et al., Wayne County Circuit Court No. 24-012254-NI.Approved, 7-0
SettlementSettlement presented by the Law Department after the closed session. Amount not stated.Approved, 7-0

Vote record

Times are elapsed from the start of the meeting video. Members are Budzinski, Persiconi, Ptashnik, Brockway, McCullough, McDonnell and Reid.
TimeMotionMoved / supportedResultVoting no
9:47Oct. 12 minutes, as correctedMover not identified / Ptashnik7-0None
48:07Reconsider sidewalk waiverBudzinski / Brockway5-2Persiconi, Reid
48:38Waive Fairlane Avenue sidewalksMcCullough / Brockway5-2Persiconi, Reid
51:03Consent agenda, items 1-6Budzinski / supporter not identified7-0None
1:27:26Item 7a, fiscal 2027 budgetPtashnik / McDonnell6-1McCullough
1:30:18Item 9, backhoeBudzinski / McDonnell7-0None
1:31:06Item 10, leaf vacuumsPtashnik / Budzinski7-0None
1:32:02Item 11, closed session (two-thirds roll call)Ptashnik / Persiconi7-0None
1:43:46Approve settlementPtashnik / Brockway7-0None
1:46:03Infrastructure referralBudzinski / Ptashnik7-0None
1:46:21AdjournMover not identified / PersiconiNo roll callNone recorded

Public comment timeline

TimeSpeakerComment
First audience communication (non-agenda items)
10:22Steve King, Coventry GardensRecalled working with Kirksey on a YMCA auction. Said the ordinance limits only the closing session to non-agenda subjects, so residents should be able to address agenda items up front. Cited 90,148 residents and 37,716 housing units from the city's Book 5 and asked how a housing unit is defined.
13:28Erica Jones, Linden ParkNew resident, closed in August 2024. Said the homeowners association has not been turned over and asked the council to look into it.
14:14Bob Klein, LivoniaSaid the dispute involving King is unresolved, "doesn't play well" on YouTube and risks "a Jerry Springer type atmosphere." Suggested King, the council and Parks and Recreation meet with the mayor. Answered an earlier speaker's remarks on a federal search of a congresswoman's home, saying warrants were signed by two judges.
17:08Elijah, LivoniaSaid the time spent on King is excessive. Asked the council and mayor for feedback and next steps on Flock surveillance cameras.
19:06Melissa, LivoniaAsked for answers on Flock, saying many cities are canceling contracts. Said Southfield is considering a data center at 11 Mile and Inkster roads, less than five miles from Livonia.
Sidewalk waiver
35:11Steve KingOpposed. Called it a safety issue near Five Mile Road and said the council has waived almost two miles of sidewalk over 10 years.
36:21ElijahCalled repeated waivers "death by a thousand cuts" for walkability and asked for a more proactive approach.
37:50Angelo Mauti, builderSaid he would have built the sidewalk had he known of the 2024 denial, that the letter went to the prior owner, that engineering approved the pour and that the sidewalk would go nowhere.
Consent agenda
49:55Steve KingQuestioned the cross-connection program, saying residential sprinkler systems must already have backflow preventers. He was told from the dais that the vote was a referral, not a contract award, and that he could return when the award comes up.
Fiscal 2027 budget
1:13:29Steve KingAsked for a line-by-line review with written justifications. Said he could cut $10 million in 10 minutes. Questioned 67 take-home vehicles and a $545,000 recreation amendment.
1:15:27Jim Beagle, LivoniaSaid a budget should be voted on from a printed document with final numbers, not an Oct. 22 list of changes. Said accessible bathrooms outrank spending $1.5 million to demolish two buildings.
1:17:28Christopher MartinOpposed. Said repeated requests about DPW trucks losing sand went unaddressed and described workers he said were idle at the senior center and library.
1:19:34ElijahQuestioned a $400,000 HVAC control system. Named Jitsi as a free, open-source alternative to Zoom and asked who checks whether contract prices are fair.
1:21:40Cindy Fleming, LivoniaSaid the capital improvement manager position was never filled and two part-time positions were combined instead. Asked for a prioritized plan. Said the Alfred Noble Library still has its 1967 HVAC system and water in the basement.
1:23:46Denise Mika, LivoniaAsked whether members' budget meetings raise Open Meetings Act concerns. Asked why two buildings would be demolished while the library roof leaks, and whether $40,000 approved to study Noble was spent. No one responded before the vote.
Second audience communication (non-agenda items)
1:32:38Denise MikaSaid "things are getting pretty contentious," that one council member "got to speak twice" and that "the other council person should have had a chance as a rebuttal." Asked the council to scrutinize bids and said the $40,000 for Noble remains unspent after about two years. On Oct. 5, Brockway cited "some 30,000" for Noble, and Director of Governmental Affairs Aarica Smith said, "That money was spent already." The sources do not show whether that is the same money.
1:33:59Christopher MartinSaid he would not approve the budget and that the city will not improve until it removes poor performers among its workers, who he said make others less productive.
1:35:59Frank McDermott, Rayburn StreetAsked the council to put on its next agenda a vote rescinding King's lifetime ban from the Senior Wellness Center and Recreation Center. Said the Recreation Commission imposed it, while the 16th District Court gave King a $50 fine plus costs for trespassing.
1:37:37Jim BeagleAsked that the corrected budget book be published. Described a Virginia speaker who stood silent for his time because, the speaker said, officials do not listen. Hoped for good candidates next year.
1:40:39Unnamed speakerTold that speakers get one turn per meeting, at either the beginning or the end, and could return at the study session.
1:41:26Brandon McCullough, as a residentAddressed Reid and called the proceedings "an embarrassment" and "orchestrated." Said he would have his say at the next meeting and pointed to next year's election.
Other agenda items and closing motions
VariousNo speakersReid called for audience comment on items 9, 10 and 11, the settlement and the infrastructure referral. No one spoke.

Council member updates timeline

TimeMemberUpdate
20:16Kayleigh Reid, presidentWarned of scammers posing as city employees and pointed to livonia.gov/directory. Announced a public hearing Nov. 23 at 6 p.m. in the auditorium and new data on item 7. Explained the planned closed session.
21:33Martha PtashnikAsked residents to complete a Southeast Michigan Urban Deer survey before Nov. 1. It takes about five minutes and responses are confidential. The city's communications department was to post it the next day.
22:20Patrick Brockway, vice presidentSaid Flock goes to the Public Safety Committee on Nov. 19 at 7 p.m. at City Hall. About a dozen questions are with the Livonia Police Department and Law Department. The committee can keep the item or send it to the council for action.
23:35Robin PersiconiAnnounced the Livonia Rotary clubs' spaghetti dinner to end polio on Oct. 28, 5-7 p.m., at Christ Our Savior Lutheran Church on Farmington Road. Announced the Livonia Elks' free Veterans Day luncheon on Nov. 9, 11 a.m.-2 p.m., at their Plymouth Road lodge, with a $10 donation for non-veteran guests.
25:05Brandon McCulloughAnnounced the Livonia Hockey Association's Night at the Races on Nov. 20 at St. Mary's and a sixth annual "get beat up by the Red Wings" fundraiser on May 15 benefiting Breaking Barriers. Recognized the life of Livonia Democratic Club President Kate Zukowski. Said a lifetime ban for King is "way too long."
27:56Carrie BudzinskiDirected the Linden Park resident to email the council for follow-up, and said members generally do not answer during public comment. Said a data center ordinance is with the Planning Commission.
28:49, 33:00Eileen McDonnellRaised the Fairlane Avenue sidewalk waiver. Said she visited the site and that forcing the sidewalk "wasn't logical" or fair to the builder.

What's next

  • Before Nov. 1: deadline given for the deer survey.
  • Nov. 9: next regular council meeting.
  • Nov. 15: under the city charter, the mayor must return the budget by this date, approving it or disapproving all of it or individual items, which the council would then reconsider. The city's budget timeline lists the same date.
  • Nov. 19, 7 p.m.: Public Safety Committee on Flock cameras.
  • Nov. 23, 6 p.m.: public hearing in the City Hall Auditorium.
  • Dec. 1: fiscal 2027 begins.
  • To be scheduled: Committee of the Whole action on the Seven Mile/Farmington and Wonderland Flats requests, committee review of the cross-connection program, and the Capital Outlay and Infrastructure Committee's infrastructure discussion.
Comments
Loading...

Log in to comment.