Skip to main content
← Back to articles

Housing Commission Seeks 3% PILOT for Golden Oaks Senior Homes at Livonia Council's Nov. 9 Study Meeting

LIVONIA — 11/14/2026

The Livonia Housing Commission asked the City Council on Nov. 9 for a payment in lieu of taxes on Golden Oaks Village, a proposed 100-unit affordable senior development on city-owned land at 11981 Newburgh Road, and the council placed the request on the consent agenda for its Nov. 23 meeting. No vote was taken. Study meetings set the agenda for the voting meeting, and all 16 items moved forward: 11 to the consent agenda and five to the regular agenda.

All seven council members attended. The meeting was called to order at 8:44 p.m. and adjourned at 9:57 p.m., according to the minutes. Also on the Nov. 23 agenda: workers' compensation coverage that Finance Director Benjamin Grier said is the lowest per $100 of payroll since the 2013-2014 renewal, the renewal of the city's property and liability coverage, and $2.56 million in final budget amendments for the fiscal year that ends Nov. 30.

Significant events

Golden Oaks Village: 100 senior homes and a 3% PILOT

Executive Director of Housing Madison Bjertness asked for a payment in lieu of taxes (PILOT) set at 3% for Golden Oaks Village, to be built by Livonia Golden Oaks Limited Dividend Housing Association, LLC. Under a PILOT, the property pays a percentage of net shelter rent, the project's rent income less vacancy and utilities, in place of ad valorem property taxes. Bjertness said a PILOT was approved for another project in June 2026.

Two development consultants from Plante Moran Realpoint, which the Housing Commission hired to guide it through the financing applications, presented the plan:

  • Homes: 100 one- and two-bedroom units in single-story, cottage-style buildings (eight or nine, the consultants said; the concept plan shows eight), plus a community center and a perimeter walking path, on 9.5 acres of city-owned land just south of Newburgh Village. The site plan is conceptual. The Housing Commission has selected RDL Architects to verify it before a submission to the Michigan State Housing Development Authority (MSHDA) in the next few weeks.
  • Need: The consultants said the Housing Commission reports a waiting list of three years or more for its three properties, McNamara Towers, Newburgh Village and Silver Village.
  • Rents: Units at 50%, 60% and 80% of area median income, averaging 60%. The consultants put 60% at $44,000 a year for one person and $50,000 for two in Wayne County. Rents must stay income-restricted for up to 50 years.
  • Financing: 4% low-income housing tax credits, which the consultants said cover about 30% of development costs; a permanent mortgage through the state bond process; Michigan's new state housing tax credit; and state gap financing, low-interest loans at 1% to 3%. The consultants said the city may later be asked for up to $500,000 in HOME funds.
  • Taxes: The site pays $0 now. Once the property is built and stabilized, the 3% PILOT would bring in about $37,000 a year, split among all taxing jurisdictions.

Council Member Eileen McDonnell asked about environmental testing, citing problems on adjacent sites. A consultant said a Phase I assessment completed in July found a recognized environmental condition on the west end of the property from a 1930s orchard. The Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy (EGLE) will pay for the Phase II testing through its Brownfield Site Assessment program, with soil sampling to begin in the next few weeks. The consultant said EGLE will notify the Housing Commission when it goes out to the site, and that residents of Newburgh Village and nearby homes will be notified as well. Bjertness said the contamination McDonnell referred to is on the far side of Newburgh Village, away from the Golden Oaks site, and that mitigation is in place. The consultant said MSHDA would require a full plan and remediation if testing finds contamination.

Council Member Carrie Budzinski placed the item on consent, saying the PILOT's effect comes after construction and the site now pays nothing. Resident Denise Mika said Mika could find no record of the council approving the Plante Moran contract, said the letter to the assessor's office is undated and the transmittal unsigned, and said one community building would not serve both properties. Bjertness answered that the Housing Commission approved the contract, that the documents will be signed and sent to the assessor's office after the council approves the PILOT, and that the new site will have its own community building.

Workers' compensation: the excess carrier lowered its price after a competing quote

Grier asked the council to approve two providers for the city's self-insured workers' compensation program from Dec. 1, 2026, to Nov. 30, 2028:

  • Claims administrator: a two-year contract at $40,000 a year, up $2,000 a year over the current level, which Grier attributed to claims processors' wages. Grier said the city's agent, Marsh, could find no one else to do it for less than $55,000 a year.
  • Excess coverage: Midwest Employers Casualty, at about $190,000 a year. Grier said the city had no competing quote "until last week," and that "today we received a new quote" of about $181,000 a year from Safety National, for a one-year term only, with lower attachment points. Grier said Marsh took that to Midwest Employers, which lowered its offer to $150,000 a year without being told the competing figure. Grier recommended Midwest Employers.

Grier said the two contracts would average $0.35 per $100 of payroll, and that the city would have to go back to the 2013-2014 renewal to find a lower price from two proven providers. The new figures went to the council by email that afternoon. Council President Kayleigh Reid said the email arrived at about 4:30 p.m. and that Reid had not read it. Council Member Robin Persiconi offered the item for consent, and another member asked to move it to the regular agenda to have time to read the material.

Property and liability insurance renewal

The city has carried property and casualty coverage through the Michigan Municipal Risk Management Authority (MMRMA), a risk pool, for more than 30 years. For the year ending Nov. 30, 2027, the city would pay $1,725,216. Grier told the council that is a 4.6% increase over the current period; the minutes record "a four percent increase." The second year's cost will be set next year, guaranteed within 8% of the current term.

Grier said the terms are largely unchanged: a $250,000 self-insured retention, liability coverage up to $15 million, real and personal property and vehicles, and sewer system overflows, which Grier said commercial carriers do not cover. The first-year cost would be offset by a $693,253 net asset distribution from MMRMA. Council Member Brandon McCullough offered consent or regular, and the item went to the regular agenda.

Final budget amendments for fiscal year 2026

Grier asked for amendments so the fiscal year 2026 budget complies with the State of Michigan's budget act before the year closes Nov. 30. Each amount is a maximum, Grier said: "We say up to so we don't have to come back."

  • Refuse Fund (226): up to $1.1 million more in spending. Leaf pickup through the city's hauler is projected up to $700,000 over budget, and recycling, composting and hazardous waste disposal up to $400,000 over. Projected year-end fund balance: $3.3 million.
  • Transit Fund: up to $120,000 more, for higher staffing costs and unexpected bus repairs, on top of a budgeted gap of about $200,000. Grier said the fund's share of the Transit and Capital Improvement Millage has not grown while service expanded. Projected fund balance: just over $605,000.
  • Cable Fund: a $225,000 transfer from the General Fund to prevent a negative fund balance, which state law prohibits. Grier said spending will run $25,000 over budget and revenue about $200,000 under.
  • Golden Oaks Fund (537): a budget of up to $115,000 for pre-development costs. Grier said the fund already holds $250,000 contributions from each of the other housing funds but had no budget to spend it. Projected fund balance: just under $313,000.
  • Water and Sewer Fund (592): $1 million more, because wholesale water purchases from the Great Lakes Water Authority exceeded the budget by that much. Projected fund balance: $35 million.

Budzinski asked whether the administration expects these costs to continue into the 2027 budget the council just approved. Ptashnik said the council made cable adjustments for next year and will take up water costs with water rates. Resident Jerry Karasinski said the requested amounts for transit, cable and Golden Oaks exceed what the city's own analysis shows is needed; Grier answered that unused authority is not spent. Persiconi offered consent, and another member asked to move the item to the regular agenda.

McCullough: the charter puts park bans with the Parks and Recreation Commission

During council announcements, McCullough read into the record that Chapter V, Section 15 of the Livonia City Charter gives the Parks and Recreation Commission management and control of all parks and recreation facilities. McCullough said that puts the ban of an individual the council has discussed outside the council's authority, comparing it to the Zoning Board of Appeals. Addressing the remarks through the chair to City Attorney Eric Goldstein, McCullough said, "I'm getting a nod that, you know, we're out of this."

Agenda table

The council votes on these items Nov. 23. "Consent" means the items are expected to pass in one motion unless a member pulls one. Placement is direction from the council, not an approval.

ItemDescriptionDetailsNov. 9 status
Approved
NoneA study meeting takes no final action. Nothing was approved.Not applicable
Denied
NoneNothing was denied, and no item was held or removed from the agenda.Not applicable
Unfinished business
NoneThe minutes list no unfinished business.Not applicable
New business: consent agenda, Nov. 23
2. Brownfield reappointmentDan West to the Livonia Brownfield Redevelopment Authority for a three-year term ending Nov. 24, 2029.West told the council in advance that West could not attend.Consent
3. Brownfield reappointmentLynda Scheel to the Livonia Brownfield Redevelopment Authority for a three-year term ending Nov. 24, 2029.Scheel attended and said Scheel was honored by the reappointment. Ptashnik said Scheel has served on the authority for some time.Consent
4. Part-time Parks and Recreation wagesWage rate and classification adjustments for part-time Parks and Recreation employees.Human Resources Director Jeannine Laible said the entry rate rises from $13.73 to $15 an hour to match Michigan's minimum wage on Jan. 1, 2027, with higher steps adjusted from there. Superintendent of Parks and Recreation Michelle Koppin said the budget anticipated an increase; the 2028 minimum wage will not be known until Nov. 1, 2027.Consent
8. Golf course maintenance roofsAward of bid for roof replacement and related repairs on the maintenance buildings at Idyl Wyld, Fox Creek and Whispering Willows golf courses, from the golf course capital fund.Koppin recommended the lower of two bidders at $224,500, plus a 10% contingency ($22,450) in place of the usual 5%, at the Finance Department's recommendation, because of the buildings' age and possible unforeseen work. Specifications posted on MITN June 29; pre-bid meeting July 9; bids received Aug. 11. Work: a new membrane roof, masonry repair and painting, and window and door infill at Idyl Wyld, the oldest building; a new shingle roof and replacement boards and fascia at Fox Creek; a new metal roof, insulation, liner panels, soffits, gutters and downspouts at Whispering Willows.Consent
9. Fitness network agreementFitness Network Location Services Agreement with American Specialty Health Fitness, Inc. for matinee memberships at the Jack E. Kirksey Recreation Center.Insurance-based memberships through the Silver&Fit and Active&Fit programs. The city would be reimbursed per member for up to eight visits a month. Koppin said more than 2,290 eligible residents live within five miles of the center. The attachment was first marked confidential in error and reposted.Consent
10. Golden Oaks Village PILOT3% payment in lieu of taxes for the affordable senior development at 11981 Newburgh Road, by Livonia Golden Oaks Limited Dividend Housing Association, LLC.100 units; about $37,000 a year once stabilized, against $0 now. See Significant events.Consent
11. Mid-Michigan Recycling leaseFive-year extension of the lease of five acres of city-owned property at 32000 Glendale Avenue to Mid-Michigan Recycling, L.C., for wood processing and disposal.$3,000 a month. First approved in 2009 and extended in 2014, 2017 and 2022. Director of Public Works Doug Moore said dump tickets from the last two years show savings to residents, the city and its contractors of about $70,000 a year, or $5,833 a month. Moore said the operation began in Plymouth Township as the state's response to the emerald ash borer and later moved to Livonia.Consent
13. Lead service line bondsNotice of intent resolution to issue water and sewer revenue bonds not to exceed $5 million, for $5 million from the Drinking Water State Revolving Fund (DWSRF) for lead service line investigation and replacement.The agenda calls the award a grant. Assistant Director of Public Works Zach Haapala said $500,000 would be forgiven and the other $4.5 million is a loan at 0% interest repaid over 20 years. Haapala called the bond notice a show of good faith to the state that the fund can carry the payment. Haapala said the Finance Department worked with the law firm Miller Canfield on the documents.Consent
14. Sidewalk waiver, Laurel DriveTomasz Nowak, 18635 Laurel Drive, N.W. ¼ of Section 9.The Engineering Department raised no objection in an Oct. 19 letter. Nowak said the street has no sidewalks and a ditch along the road. Vice President Patrick Brockway said aerial maps show no sidewalks nearby.Consent
15. BS&A cloud softwareBS&A cloud-based software, licensing and training, $23,215 total, with an annual increase not to exceed 5%.City Engineer Todd Zilincik gave the parts as a $17,870 annual fee, $1,070 for project management and planning and up to $4,275 for implementation and training. It would let Engineering take electronic plan submissions, mark up drawings in Bluebeam and track reviews with the building, fire and engineering departments, as the building department already does.Consent
16. Act 51 street certificationsAdditions and decertifications to the local street system for the 2027 Act 51 computations, for streets newly opened or no longer open to traffic in 2026.Zilincik said four additions and five decertifications make a small net loss; the transcript gives the figure as both 991 and 99.1 linear feet. The system stays at about 375 miles. Zilincik said road mileage drives about $14 million a year in state funding, and the certified map runs through June 30, 2027.Consent
New business: regular agenda, Nov. 23
1. Petition 2026-09-02-24Infinity Acquisitions, LLC: waiver use approval under Sections 3.16 and 6.58 of the Zoning Ordinance for outdoor storage tied to a special trades contractor at 34426 Rosati Avenue, north side, S.W. ¼ of Section 28.The Planning Commission recommended approval, subject to review of additional landscaping on the front of the property. Planning and Economic Development Director Mark Taormina said the owner is a real estate development company that also owns a landscape company; the half-acre site backs onto the railroad in an industrial park, the building is nearly finished, and storage would include equipment, materials and a fuel tank. Mulch may be stored up to 8 feet high, typically in three-sided bins. The petitioner was absent. A member asked for the regular agenda to hear from the petitioner about adjoining owners' concerns over landscape materials.Regular
5. Workers' compensationAward of contract for workers' compensation coverage, Dec. 1, 2026, to Nov. 30, 2028, from budgeted funds.Claims administrator at $40,000 a year; Midwest Employers Casualty excess coverage at $150,000 a year. See Significant events.Regular
6. MMRMA renewalLiability and property insurance with the Michigan Municipal Risk Management Authority, Dec. 1, 2026, to Nov. 30, 2028.$1,725,216 for the first year, less a $693,253 distribution. 4.6% increase per Grier; "four percent" per the minutes. See Significant events.Regular
7. Budget amendmentsBudget adjustments for the fiscal year ending Nov. 30, 2026.Refuse $1.1 million, transit $120,000, cable $225,000 General Fund transfer, Golden Oaks $115,000, water and sewer $1 million. See Significant events.Regular
12. Water metersContract with Etna Supply Company, the sole source provider of Sensus meters in Michigan, for water meters and supplies, not to exceed $750,000, from budgeted funds.A one-year extension. Haapala said Etna has been the sole source for the city's meter parts for 10 years, that the city has replaced about 14,000 of its just under 37,000 residential meters with Sensus meters from Etna, and that Etna is holding last year's prices. Ptashnik offered consent; a member asked for the regular agenda because of the cost.Regular

Vote record

The council took no votes on Nov. 9. Each row below is direction from a member on where an item goes, accepted without objection, with the member named in the minutes. Where another member asked for the regular agenda, the transcript does not identify who. The votes are pending for the regular meeting on Nov. 23.

Times are elapsed from the start of the meeting video. Present: Budzinski, Persiconi, Ptashnik, Brockway, McCullough, McDonnell and Reid. Absent: none.
TimeItemMember offering directionPlacement
10:101. Rosati Avenue storageCarrie Budzinski offered either; a member asked for regular at 10:29Regular
12:332. Dan WestRobin PersiconiConsent
13:113. Lynda ScheelMartha PtashnikConsent
15:164. Part-time wagesCarrie BudzinskiConsent
20:355. Workers' compensationRobin Persiconi offered consent; a member asked for regular at 21:10Regular
24:436. MMRMA renewalBrandon McCullough offered consent or regular; regular chosen at 24:51Regular
34:267. Budget amendmentsRobin Persiconi offered consent; a member asked for regular at 34:46Regular
38:308. Golf course roofsRobin PersiconiConsent
40:179. Fitness networkMartha PtashnikConsent
51:4710. Golden Oaks PILOTCarrie BudzinskiConsent
57:0111. Recycling leaseCarrie BudzinskiConsent
58:4512. Water metersMartha Ptashnik offered consent; a member asked for regular at 58:54Regular
1:00:2713. Lead service line bondsMartha PtashnikConsent
1:01:2414. Sidewalk waiverPatrick BrockwayConsent
1:03:3315. BS&A softwareBrandon McCulloughConsent
1:04:5616. Act 51 certificationsPatrick BrockwayConsent

Public comment timeline

TimeSpeakerComment
First audience communication (non-agenda items)
1:04Chris Muldoon, Emerson Oaks homeowners associationSaid homeowners associations have no seat at the table when the city and a developer settle a new development's common areas, and asked for a policy change at the building, inspection and engineering levels to give them one. Said the developer used bath silicone to set letters in the concrete monument sign and laid seed on clay. Said the bond money went back to the developer once the city signed off, leaving the association to ask 35 residents to pay for repairs; the development is worth more than $10 million. Said the association was turned over to residents in 2024, before the neighborhood was complete.
4:16Noah Wojcik, LivoniaReturning to an election topic, suggested the city consider voter assist terminals, touchscreen machines for voters with disabilities. Said the City of Ecorse, where Wojcik works as an election inspector, has one and that Wayne County encourages them.
Item 7, budget amendments
34:58Jerry Karasinski, LivoniaSaid the requested amendments for the transit, cable and Golden Oaks funds are larger than the amounts the city's analysis shows are needed. Grier answered that the amounts are maximums and that unused authority is not spent.
Item 10, Golden Oaks PILOT
52:27Denise Mika, LivoniaSaid Plante Moran was chosen as consultant in February but Mika could find no record of the council approving the contract; that the letter to the assessor's office is undated and the transmittal unsigned; that Housing Commission members discuss materials the public cannot see; and that 100 more residents would need another activity center. Asked for more information to be posted. Bjertness answered at 54:32.
Closing audience communication (non-agenda items)
1:05:29Denise MikaAsked whether departments must bring contracts over $30,000 to the council. Cited $83,570 in Fund 537 and said that the Housing Commission picked Plante Moran in February, that Mika saw no contract award come to the council, and that the contract was described as worth $90,000 at a Housing Commission meeting.
1:06:58Jerry KarasinskiSaid the budget process needs more due diligence up front, that, according to a letter from Grier, changes found during the budget process were not put back into the proposed budget, and that purchasing is not always rigorous. Said narrowing margins between revenue and spending, rising material costs and labor contracts call for more efficiency.
1:09:10Jim Biga, LivoniaRead the charter's contracts and purchases section, Section 13, which makes the council responsible for letting contracts. Asked whether the Housing Commission is part of the city, and if not, why its budget is in the city's. Suggested the council receive a list of requests for proposals over $25,000. Said Biga and Karasinski will track the $6.8 million in capital spending through next year.

Council member updates timeline

TimeSpeakerUpdate
0:13Kayleigh Reid, presidentOpened the meeting and said the items go to a vote at the regular meeting Nov. 23, with all seven members present.
6:12Robin PersiconiAsked to refer vape and smoke shops to the Public Safety and Health Committee. Told that a study meeting cannot take the referral, Persiconi said it would be raised at the next meeting.
6:47Brandon McCulloughCited Chapter V, Section 15 of the city charter, which gives the Parks and Recreation Commission control of parks and recreation facilities, as the reason the council cannot act on a banned individual. See Significant events.
32:01Carrie BudzinskiDuring item 7, asked whether the overruns will carry into the 2027 budget.
33:35Martha PtashnikAnswered that the council adjusted cable for next year and will address water costs when it sets water rates.
49:07Eileen McDonnellDuring item 10, asked about EGLE testing on the Golden Oaks site.
1:12:11Robin PersiconiAnswered the closing comments on the Housing Commission: it came to the council only because a PILOT affects taxes paid to the city; it keeps its own budget, deals with federal grants and the voucher program, and runs Newburgh and Silver Village on their own rent income; and its commissioners approve contracts such as Plante Moran's, as Persiconi did as a housing commissioner. Said residents who want to follow the development should attend Housing Commission meetings.

Where the sources differ

  • Insurance increase: Grier said 4.6%; the minutes say four percent.
  • Pledge of Allegiance: On the video, Reid introduces Ptashnik to lead the pledge; the minutes say Persiconi led it.
  • Lead service line funding: The agenda calls the $5 million a grant. Haapala and the minutes describe a loan, 10% of it forgiven.

What's next

  • Next few weeks: EGLE soil sampling at the Golden Oaks site; site plan submission to MSHDA.
  • Monday, Nov. 23: Regular meeting, with votes on all 16 items.
  • Monday, Nov. 30: Fiscal year 2026 ends.
  • Tuesday, Dec. 1: New workers' compensation and MMRMA coverage terms begin, if approved.
  • Friday, Jan. 1, 2027: Michigan's minimum wage rises to $15, according to Laible.
Comments
Loading...

Log in to comment.