Planning Commission Approves Larger Mobil Store, Postpones Crooks Road Townhouses
ROYAL OAK — 11/14/2026
Commissioners approved a larger convenience store at the Mobil station on Woodward Avenue at 13 Mile Road, approved outdoor display and storage for an upscale resale shop while rejecting vehicle sales there, and sent both the shop's site plan and an 11-unit townhouse plan on Crooks Road back for revisions.
ROYAL OAK — The Royal Oak Planning Commission on Tuesday, Nov. 10, approved a site plan to expand the convenience store at the Mobil station at 31001 Woodward Ave., at 13 Mile Road. The plan from Safiedine Oil Co. grows the store from about 1,900 to about 3,200 square feet, adds a carry-out restaurant and sets aside four parking spaces for electric vehicle charging. The motion attached the contingencies listed by city staff.
On a second item, commissioners approved a special land use for outdoor display and outdoor storage at Everything Home Upscale Resale, 29862 Woodward Ave., and the neighboring former restaurant building at 29838 Woodward. They rejected the vehicle sales the owner had also requested, which a speaker for the business later withdrew. Commissioners postponed the site plan for the two properties to their next regular meeting and asked for a revised drawing. Director of Planning Joseph Murphy said code enforcement had been to the property more than 50 times over several years.
The commission also postponed a request by builder D.W. Krane to rezone 3122 and 3132 Crooks Road from Two-Family Residential to Planned Unit Development for 11 attached homes, which the agenda calls Indian Knolls. Commissioners asked to see the side of the buildings that faces Crooks Road first. A rezoning goes to the City Commission for the final decision; the Planning Commission's role is a recommendation.
All votes were by voice. No opposing votes were heard on any motion, and the recording does not include a roll call.
Summary of actions
The Planning Commission's agenda has no consent agenda and no unfinished business section. Its numbered items are the approval of minutes, public comment, new business and other business. The table follows that order.
| Category | Item | Outcome | Details |
|---|---|---|---|
| Consent agenda | None | Not applicable | The Nov. 10 agenda does not include a consent agenda. |
| Routine | Item 2. Approval of minutes, Oct. 13, 2026 | Not in the recording | The transcript has no text before 56 seconds into the recording, so the minutes vote is not in it. |
| Public comment | Item 3. Items not on the agenda | No speakers heard | The transcript picks up at 0:56 with the words "items not on our agenda" and resumes 20 seconds later with staff's presentation on the first public hearing. No speaker is heard. |
| Approved: new business | Item 4c. SP 26-11-15, site plan, 31001 Woodward Ave. (parcel 25-06-455-009), Mobil station at 13 Mile Road | Approved with staff contingencies | Petitioner and owner: Safiedine Oil Co. Engineer: Umlor Group. The plan adds a rear addition to the convenience store, growing it from about 1,900 to about 3,200 square feet, with a carry-out restaurant. Asked about it, a speaker for the petitioner said it will have no seating or drive-thru and that whether it is branded has not been confirmed. It adds parking on the south side over the underground fuel tanks and four EV-charging spaces closest to the intersection. Staff said 13 spaces are required and 13 compliant spaces are provided. Staff questioned two more spaces, one on the north side and one near the EV spaces that sits in the turning radius for two-way traffic around the pumps. Staff said a landscape plan, including frontage trees in the right-of-way, has not been submitted. Staff and the owner disagree on how many drive approaches will close (see below). |
| Approved: new business | Item 4b, part 1. Special land use, SP 26-11-14, 29838 and 29862 Woodward Ave. (parcels 25-08-326-009 and 25-08-326-022) | Outdoor display and outdoor storage approved; vehicle sales rejected | Petitioner and property owner: Jennifer Marie Properties, LLC. The business on the site is Everything Home Upscale Resale. Architect: J.T. Holowicki. Engineer: J.S. Sweda. The motion approved outdoor display of merchandise and outdoor storage, with the form of the storage to be set in the site plan, and voted against vehicle sales. A speaker for the business withdrew the vehicle sales request during the hearing. Murphy said exterior storage where the parking would be removed is neither a permitted nor a special land use in the General Business district, and would need a Zoning Board of Appeals variance, as would the reduced number of off-street parking spaces. Asked later whether the storage containers would still go to the ZBA even with the special land use, Murphy said yes. |
| Postponed: new business | Item 4b, part 2. Site plan, same properties: second-story addition and retail boutique in the former restaurant building at 29838 Woodward | Postponed to the next regular meeting | The revised plan is to show: parking reworked with compliant ADA parking; the exact area for outdoor display; the limits and details of outdoor storage; the Woodward front of the boutique building, either with the window shown on the plan or with what replaces it, such as a mural; and responses to every comment in the staff report, including a dumpster enclosure. Before the motion, a commissioner also asked that references to vehicle sales come off the plan. |
| Postponed: new business | Item 4a. Rezoning from Two-Family Residential to Planned Unit Development and preliminary PUD site plan, SP 26-11-13, 3122 and 3132 Crooks Road (parcels 25-09-101-006 and 25-09-101-007) | Postponed to the next regular meeting | Petitioner: D.W. Krane. Owner of record: David M. Munn Trust. Architect: Stucky Vitale Architects. The plan would demolish a single-family home and a four-unit building and build 11 three-bedroom attached homes in two buildings, of five and six units, facing an interior drive. Seven units would have one-car garages and four would have two-car garages. Murphy said the density matches what the multiple-family district would allow on the lot. The requested deviations cover the use, the setbacks for both buildings and the buildings' height-to-width ratios. Commissioners asked to see the west elevation, the side facing Crooks Road, before deciding. |
| Denied | Vehicle sales at 29838 and 29862 Woodward Ave. | Rejected within the special land use motion | This was the only part of any request voted down. A speaker for the business had already said it did not need it. |
| Other business | Item 5a. Receive and file | Received, no action | Staff's list of administrative approvals for the last quarter and the Road Commission for Oakland County's third-quarter report. A commissioner noted that the staff list included an Amazon facility in warehouse space on Hudson, behind B&B Collision. |
Significant events
- Staff and the owner gave different counts of driveways closing at Woodward and 13 Mile. Murphy said the petitioner had agreed to remove two of the site's four drive approaches, the one on Woodward and the one on 13 Mile closest to the intersection. The property owner said only one approach would close. The approval motion adopted staff's contingencies and did not address the difference.
- Staff and the owner disagreed on the resale shop's application fee. Murphy said the petitioner had not paid the application fee and that staff brought the request forward anyway because the property had been a recurring code enforcement matter for several years. The owner said the $1,500 fee had been paid and promised to look into it the next morning.
- Vehicle sales came off the table during the hearing. The owner and a family member said the business sells an occasional car from an estate sale and is not a dealership. In the presentation, the owner said vehicles are generally a handful a year, mostly out-of-state sales; in questioning, a speaker for the business said about a dozen since 2011. The business offered to drop the request. Murphy said the city could not confirm a state dealer license application at the site, because the plans do not meet state requirements for an office, signage and dedicated parking.
- A resident spoke for the older house on the Crooks Road site. Charlie Ecker asked that the house, which Ecker said is now a four-unit rental, be worked into the development rather than demolished. Ecker said its records go back, Ecker believed, to the 1880s. Replying from the commission table, a speaker the transcript does not name said the house was built in 1901, has no documented historical significance and has no historic protection.
- The mayor suggested a mural where a window is missing. A speaker for the business said the boutique would not have the first-floor picture window drawn on the plan, to keep showroom space and for security, since it would sell luxury goods. Mayor Michael Fournier suggested, as an idea and not a condition, a mural through the city's Commission for the Arts. When a speaker for the business proposed painting designer brand names on the wall, a speaker at the commission table said that would count as a sign, not a mural.
Mobil station, 31001 Woodward Ave.
The property owner told commissioners the station has been the owner's father-in-law's since 1990 or 1991. The owner said the company has been in business more than 50 years and runs more than 60 stores in Southeast Michigan. The station will be redeveloped as a location of the company's convenience-store chain, with EV charging and a food-service restaurant, the owner said.
A representative with MHA, which the owner named as the project architect, said the spaces over the fuel tank openings would be signed for 15-minute parking. Fuel deliveries are scheduled overnight, off peak, the representative said, and the schedule would not change. The representative also asked whether a bike rack could count toward required parking if a space is removed. A commissioner said the site already meets the requirement with 13 spaces, so removing the two questioned spaces would leave it in compliance.
A commissioner said the city has had trouble in the past with oil companies wanting sign heights the ordinance does not allow. A representative of Umlor Group, the project's civil engineer, said signage would be handled under a separate sign permit with the Building Department, which had already flagged the limits.
Commissioners who spoke supported the plan. One called it a needed refresh for a prominent corner. Another said stations in Royal Oak and elsewhere that made similar changes now have good food offerings. That commissioner also said the EV charging fits the character of Royal Oak, and that the two questioned spaces were acceptable where drawn or could be moved near the EV spaces. No member of the public spoke; it was not a public hearing, since no special land use was involved.
Everything Home Upscale Resale, 29838 and 29862 Woodward Ave.
What was proposed
The two adjacent properties are on the east side of Woodward Avenue just north of 12 Mile Road. The resale showroom at 29862 would continue as it is, adding outdoor display, outdoor storage and vehicle sales. The smaller one-story block building at 29838, which once held the Siam Spicy carry-out restaurant, would become a ground-floor retail boutique. A second-story addition would hold storage, with glass on the upper floor to show mannequins. The plan would also remove all the parking spaces between the building and the public alley and use the area for exterior storage.
Murphy said the business has used the two parking spaces nearest the showroom door for outdoor sales for several years. Code enforcement has been out more than 50 times and issued citations, Murphy said. The plan shows no refuse enclosure, and a space drawn for vehicles for sale blocks a required egress door, according to Murphy. A speaker for the business said the door swings fully open against the wall and the architect may have drawn it wrong.
The owner's case
The owner said the business opened in 2011 and handles high-end furniture and home goods, estate sales, consignment and property liquidation. The owner asked that two storage trailers at the rear of the property be allowed to stay permanently. In questioning, speakers for the business said the trailers hold donations that are dropped off, often after hours, until they are sorted, and are empty about half the time. The patio furniture display is seasonal, and those spaces go back to parking when not in use, according to the owner. A previous code enforcement officer, now retired, accepted the containers as long as they had wheels, speakers for the business said; the citations began under the officer's successor. They said the business recently bought a building in Ferndale, where most of its trailers are now kept, and that the aerial photo in the staff report is very old.
A family member said the business has eight trailers, five enclosed and three open: six in Ferndale and two behind the Royal Oak shop.
What commissioners said
A commissioner said store staff had mentioned an off-site warehouse, noted the business's large newer location in Ferndale, and asked why exterior storage trailers were needed in Royal Oak. Commissioner Sharlan Douglas said the trailers are visible to customers of the businesses just east of the alley. A speaker for the business replied that the neighbors are not impeded and shop at the store. In the public hearing, a family member said those customers enter Scrubbers dog wash and its neighbors from Webster Road, at the front.
The chair said the request was "10 pounds of dirt trying to go into a five pound bucket," meaning the plan works only by giving up parking spaces and storing trailers. Asked whether the trailers ever move or are licensed, a speaker for the business said they had been used and that only one pickup truck the family has can tow them. A commissioner suggested hard-bodied storage units instead of trailers. The family said a code enforcement officer had told them to replace a container without wheels with a wheeled one. A commissioner said a permanent box such as a shipping container would be better than trailers that sit in place, and a speaker for the business agreed and offered to paint it to match the building.
Asked whether a business's trailer parked behind its building differs from these, Murphy said spaces required for parking can be used only for customer or employee vehicles. A trailer in one used for storage becomes a storage item, Murphy said. Murphy also said that if the commission denied outdoor storage as a special land use, the owner could not take it to the Zoning Board of Appeals.
On outdoor display, commissioners who spoke supported it. One compared it to plant sales around Mother's Day, so long as it stays in a designated space. Another compared it to English Gardens, if it is seasonal. One commissioner said the parking deficiency was not a concern, because customers would stay away from a store without enough parking.
The site plan
Brian Cooper listed what the revised plan should show, and the motion to postpone followed that list. Speakers for the business said the boutique would not have the first-floor picture window drawn on the plan, calling it an architect's oversight. The building would have a glass front door with a side window and two glass rear doors, they said, plus the upper-floor display windows. They said a window would take away showroom space, and cited security, since the boutique would sell luxury goods such as Chanel, Gucci, Prada and Louis Vuitton. Staff said the ordinance requires refuse to be enclosed if it is kept outside, but does not require a dumpster. A speaker for the business said it produces about one bag of trash a week, taken home. Murphy said each property can function independently, so no recorded access easement is needed. A commissioner said the commission cannot approve a site plan with uncertain dimensions, called the ADA space critical, and said staff could advise on fixes.
Townhouses at 3122 and 3132 Crooks Road
The two properties are on the east side of Crooks Road just south of 13 Mile Road. One holds a single-family home and the other a four-unit multiple-family building, Murphy said. The city's master plan designates the area Neighborhood Main Street, which calls for a mix of uses with ground-floor commercial. Murphy asked commissioners to keep that in mind. Preliminary PUD approval would give the petitioner six months to return with full details for a final recommendation to the City Commission. Murphy said it would amount to approval of the use and the design concept. Murphy said the plan provides more parking than required and that no landscape plan was in the packet, which is standard at the preliminary stage. A landscape plan would have to show which trees are kept and which are removed.
Krane said this type of development is similar to Krane's work of the last 37 or 38 years, and that Krane developed the Indian Mound condominiums across the street in 1988. The units would follow a Craftsman style, Krane said. Asked what the side facing Crooks Road would look like, Krane said it would be very similar to the front elevation, with brick veneer, cedar siding, cedar shake and gable dormers. Each would have a full basement and a first-floor primary bedroom and laundry, with two bedrooms upstairs. Units would be at least about 1,530 square feet, with end units of 2,000, according to Krane. Krane handed commissioners a list of the planned trees and plantings. There would be no pedestrian entrances from Crooks, only patio doors to 10-foot patios behind a privacy fence, Krane said.
Cooper asked whether the back of one building crossed the 10-foot easement around the property. Krane said that was a 2-foot overhang. Cooper also asked how trash trucks would turn around on the dead-end drive, and Krane said they back out, as at Krane's past developments. Krane said the previous owners of Indian Mound had called, but no neighbors on the adjacent street had contacted Krane.
Douglas said the area is unlikely to develop as a commercial node and that the plan is "textbook missing middle housing," the type of housing the master plan calls for. Douglas said patios along Crooks are not the look the street needs. Another commissioner suggested covered rear porches. Fournier said Crooks is a residential street where people are neighbors, and that seeing the west elevation was critical. A commissioner called the architecture spot on and said owner-occupied units are needed in that part of town. Another commissioner said Krane does not build "schlocky buildings" but that a PUD requires a higher level of detail and the Crooks side should be seen. Staff reminded the commission it could deny the request or postpone it for a modified concept. A commissioner moved to postpone so Krane could return at the next meeting with the west elevation, and Cooper supported the motion.
Votes
All votes were voice votes, and no opposing votes were heard. Where the recording does not identify the mover or supporter, the table says so.
| Recording time | Motion | Mover / Support | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 24:13 | Postpone the Crooks Road rezoning and preliminary PUD site plan (SP 26-11-13) so the petitioner can return with the west elevation at the next meeting | A commissioner (not identified in the recording) / Brian Cooper | Carried, no opposition heard |
| 1:10:10 | Approve the special land use for outdoor display of merchandise and outdoor storage, with storage addressed in the site plan, and deny vehicle sales, at 29838 and 29862 Woodward (SP 26-11-14) | Sharlan Douglas / support not identified in the recording | Carried, no opposition heard |
| 1:33:58 | Postpone the site plan for 29838 and 29862 Woodward to the next regular meeting for the revisions listed above | Brian Cooper / Sharlan Douglas | Carried, no opposition heard |
| 1:54:15 | Approve the site plan for 31001 Woodward (SP 26-11-15) with the contingencies specified by staff | Not clearly identified in the recording | Carried, no opposition heard |
| 1:57:01 | Adjourn | Brian Cooper / a second commissioner | Carried |
Public comment
Times are positions in the meeting recording. Speakers were given three minutes each, as the chair restated at the second hearing.
- 0:56 Items not on the agenda: The transcript picks up here and resumes 20 seconds later with staff's first presentation. No speaker is heard.
- 13:44 Crooks Road public hearing opened.
- 14:39 Charlie Ecker said Ecker was not speaking against the project in its entirety, was not entirely against the density and noted the existing town homes across the street. Ecker spoke for the house on the site, saying the Starr family was involved with it and its records go back, Ecker believed, to the 1880s. Ecker cited a proposal in Troy, which Ecker believed was at Square Lake and Livernois roads, where community members asked to preserve older houses and the attached town homes were planned around them. Ecker said keeping the house could preserve four smaller rental units, and acknowledged it has no historic protection.
- 17:01 A speaker at the commission table, not named in the transcript, replied that the house was built in 1901, has no documented historical significance and has "just been a rundown house for many, many years," unlike the John Almon Starr House across the street. The speaker said the city's historic district committee had not approached anyone about the house.
- 17:42 Crooks Road public hearing closed.
- 54:02 Everything Home public hearing opened for public speakers, after the owner's presentation.
- 54:24 Chris Enright, who said Enright lives relatively close to the site and submits site plans and special use applications, said Enright supports destination retailers and the owner's investment. Enright said the staff report was hard to follow, asked for one cohesive plan to scale, and said some trailers appear mislabeled. Enright said the plan needs a van-accessible barrier-free space and should be tightened up before approval.
- 56:05 Janelle, a family member of the owner (surname not clear in the recording), said the business has eight trailers, six in Ferndale and two behind the Royal Oak shop. The two have not been moved in years, Janelle said, and hold donations to be sorted for families in need. Janelle said the alley also serves a neighboring parking lot with a large fenced dumpster, and that the business is not a dealership and sells a car only rarely. Janelle's time ran out at the three-minute limit.
- 1:00:52 Everything Home public hearing closed.
- 1:48:19 Mobil site plan: The chair invited comment though it was not a public hearing. No one spoke.
Commissioner and staff comments
The Planning Commission has no council members. These are the comments from commissioners and staff outside the motions above.
- 1:56:01 A commissioner said staff's list of administrative approvals included an Amazon facility in a warehouse on Hudson, behind B&B Collision. The commissioner said that type of facility allows much quicker deliveries, including Amazon's 30-minute delivery concept.
- 1:56:53 The chair called for a motion to adjourn. The meeting adjourned shortly after 1:57 into the recording.
What's next
The Crooks Road townhouse plan and the Everything Home site plan are expected back at the commission's next regular meeting, which the city's 2026 schedule lists as Tuesday, Dec. 8, 2026, at 7 p.m. If the site plan is approved, exterior storage and the parking reduction at the resale shop would also need Zoning Board of Appeals variances, Murphy said. The Crooks Road rezoning goes to the City Commission for the final decision after the Planning Commission's recommendation.
Comments are open below.
Sources: transcript of the City of Royal Oak Nov. 10, 2026 Planning Commission meeting recording, and the meeting agenda; City of Royal Oak 2026 Planning Commission meeting schedule; city staff directory.

