Skip to main content
← Back to articles

Troy appeals board approves Burkoff Drive fence with aluminum condition, holds Sept. 2 minutes

TROY — 11/14/2026

Troy's Building Code Board of Appeals on Nov. 4 approved a fence variance for a corner lot at 3874 Burkoff Drive, on the condition that every section of fence inside the 40-foot front setback along Martinique Drive be a 4-foot, non-obscuring aluminum fence instead of the 6-foot wood privacy fence proposed for part of it. The vote was 4-0. The board also put off, for a second time in the same meeting, approval of its Sept. 2 minutes, after city staff and two members asked for corrections to how the minutes describe the board's discussion of a sauna on Hale Drive.

Four of the board's five members attended the regular meeting at Troy City Hall, 500 W. Big Beaver Road: Chair Gary Abitheira, Teresa Brooks, Matthew Dziurman and Sande Frisen. Chris Wilson, the assistant city manager, did not attend. Residential Plans Examiner and Building Inspector Dominic Abate presented the case, and Recording Secretary Kathy L. Czarnecki called the roll. Every vote taken was 4-0. No motion failed. The board withdrew one motion, a motion to deny the fence variance, before it came to a vote.

Significant events

Fence variance approved with an aluminum condition for the setback

Joshua Randolph's lot at the corner of Burkoff and Martinique counts as a corner lot under the city zoning ordinance, with front lot lines on both streets. In the R-1B zoning district, the front yard setback is 40 feet on both streets, and fences inside it are limited to 30 inches. Randolph applied to run a 4-foot aluminum fence 77 feet along Martinique, 40 feet back to the north side of the house and 13 feet along the rear property line, plus a 6-foot wood privacy fence for 27 feet along the rear property line, according to the agenda. That is 157 feet needing a variance out of 316 feet of fence in all. The other 159 feet complies with the ordinance.

Randolph told the board the family moved in about six weeks earlier, has a dog and plans to have children soon, and wants a fence that a person or animal cannot step over. Most of the trees that lined Martinique and the rear lot line were dead, Randolph said, and the open aluminum fence would leave more visibility for the neighbors' driveway than the trees did. The written application says that without the variance the family would lose nearly 40% of its yard.

Dziurman moved to deny the request, saying it would adversely affect nearby properties and that the petitioner had not shown a hardship or practical difficulty. Members then split over the neighbor's driveway on Martinique, next to the rear lot line. Frisen said a similar open aluminum fence stands about a block and a half away and that the aluminum sections did not bother him much, but that he generally opposed the 6-foot wood section. Dziurman said he was concerned that even a 4-foot open fence next to the driveway and side-entry garage would be a hazard. A member said the driveway visibility concern went away after a site visit showed the neighborhood's other open fences. Brooks said cutting back the corner was not needed because the fence is non-obscuring. A preference for setting the fence a foot off the sidewalk and rear property line was also raised; the motion as made did not mention it.

Randolph was called back to the podium and told that only four members were present, so a 2-2 tie would mean a denial, and that the board has no December meeting, so a postponement could push the case to January or February. Abate said a denied applicant can reapply with a proposal that differs from the one denied, and that the changes discussed would count. Randolph, who had already said the family would accept an all-aluminum fence, said he would take the vote.

Dziurman withdrew the denial motion. Frisen moved approval with the 27-foot wood section changed to 4-foot aluminum, so that the entire fence inside the 40-foot setback is 4-foot and non-obscuring. Frisen cited a hardship from the lot's width compared with its neighbors': its rear lot line measures 115 feet, and members put it at about 15 to 20 feet wider than neighboring lots. A member asked Frisen to add a 25-foot corner sight triangle. Frisen declined. Brooks supported the motion, and it carried 4-0. Two members urged Randolph to work with the neighbor, and Randolph was asked to call city staff the next morning to go over next steps.

Sept. 2 minutes held for corrections

The draft Sept. 2 minutes cover the board's 4-1 vote that day to grant Steve Dickerson a variance for a roughly 100-square-foot detached sauna at 5268 Hale Drive with a wood-burning heater built to a European standard. Abitheira, Dziurman, Frisen and Wilson voted yes and Brooks voted no, according to the draft. The heater is not listed and labeled by a nationally recognized testing laboratory, as the 2015 Michigan Residential Code requires, according to the draft.

Abate said he had reviewed the meeting video and asked for three clarifications to the record:

  • A statement at the September meeting that the applicant met all applicable code requirements was not accurate. The heater did not, Abate said, which is why the case came to the board.
  • A comparison of the indoor sauna heater to outdoor wood-burning heaters sold at big-box stores did not apply, Abate said, because the two are not comparable.
  • A member had said he would have liked the building official to rule on the heater under code Section R104.11. Abate said the building official could not, because the heater is not listed and labeled as the code requires.

Frisen asked for a correction of his own. The draft says he wanted an opinion from a professional engineering firm "that might support the opinion of the building official." Frisen said he meant one that would support the applicant's claim and give the building official a basis for approval. Dziurman, whom the draft minutes credit with the big-box comparison, said his point was that many devices sold in the city are not UL-listed, so a denial based on a UL rating alone lacked merit. Dziurman said everything else about the structure met code and that the heater was the only reason for the denial.

Brooks asked that the city attorney review any changes made to the minutes of an approval after the hearing. Later in the meeting, a member said, "I would rather not get the city attorney involved," and agreed with Frisen's approach. Czarnecki said the minutes are brief summaries, that building codes are outside the recording secretary's experience and that anyone can review the video for a speaker's intent. Czarnecki suggested working out the wording with Abate. The board first postponed the item until after the hearing of cases (agenda item 4), then postponed it to its next meeting so that Abate, Frisen and Dziurman's corrections could be written into a revised draft.

2027 meeting dates set

The board adopted its 2027 meeting schedule, moving two dates a week later: July 7 to July 14, and Aug. 4 to Aug. 11. Members cited vacation plans around the Independence Day holiday, observed Monday, July 5, and conflicts on Aug. 4. The full list of 2027 dates was not read aloud. There is no December 2026 meeting. The city's meeting schedule lists the Dec. 2 meeting as canceled.

Board actions

Items on the Nov. 4, 2026 agenda, plus matters raised at the meeting. Roll calls are detailed under "All votes." The board has no consent agenda; every item was taken up and voted on separately.
ItemWhat it doesOutcomeVote
Approved
3.AFence height variance, 3874 Burkoff Drive, Joshua Randolph (Chapter 83, Fence Code). Corner lot in the R-1B district, with front lot lines on Burkoff and Martinique and a 40-foot front setback on each where fences are limited to 30 inches. Approved with a condition: all fence inside the 40-foot setback is 4-foot, non-obscuring aluminum. The 27-foot section proposed as 6-foot wood privacy fence along the rear lot line becomes 4-foot aluminum. Reasons stated in the motion: not contrary to the public interest or general purpose, no adverse effect on nearby properties, and a hardship in the lot's width compared with neighboring lots. A 25-foot corner sight triangle was proposed and not added.Approved with condition4-0
42027 meeting schedule, with July 7 moved to July 14 and Aug. 4 moved to Aug. 11.Approved4-0
Consent agenda
NoneThe Building Code Board of Appeals agenda has no consent agenda. The minutes, the only routine item, were taken up on their own (item 2, below).Not applicableNone
Denied
3.AMotion to deny the 3874 Burkoff variance as submitted, moved by Dziurman, citing an adverse effect on nearby properties and no shown hardship. Withdrawn by Dziurman, with the agreement of the member who supported it, after the discussion. It never came to a vote.WithdrawnNone
NoneNo motion failed and no request was denied.NoneNone
Unfinished business
2Minutes of the Sept. 2, 2026 meeting. Postponed first to agenda item 4, after the hearing of cases, then to the next meeting, so that a revised draft can include corrections from Abate, Frisen and Dziurman on the 5268 Hale sauna case. Brooks asked that the city attorney review the changes; later, a member said they would rather not involve the attorney. No motion was made on that.Postponed twice4-0, 4-0
4Draft opening statement for the chair to read at the start of each meeting. Members still owe Abate comments, which no one had sent. Members agreed to email them before the next meeting, and Abate said he will redistribute the draft.HeldNone
New business raised at the meeting (no formal vote)
6Procedure training. A member asked whether the training the board received from City Clerk Aileen Dickson on motions and procedure should be repeated regularly, and said they believed the Zoning Board of Appeals meets annually with city legal staff on motions. A participant offered to send members notes from the training, and a member suggested a short summary of Robert's Rules of Order with the resolution template.Notes to be sharedNone
6No December meeting. Abate confirmed an email sent that day saying there will be no December meeting.NotedNone
Other agenda items
4Communications: the opening statement and the 2027 schedule, both above.NoneNone
5Public comment on items not on the agenda: no one spoke.NoneNone

All votes

Times are elapsed time in the city's meeting video. Members are listed in the order the roll was called. No member voted no. Wilson was absent for every vote.
TimeItemMovedSupportedYesResult
7:39Postpone approval of Sept. 2 minutes to agenda item 4, after the hearing of casesNot identified on videoNot identified on videoBrooks, Dziurman, Frisen, AbitheiraCarried 4-0
12:52Deny the 3874 Burkoff variance as submittedDziurmanNot identified on videoNoneWithdrawn at 34:55, no vote
36:44Approve the 3874 Burkoff variance with all fence in the setback as 4-foot aluminumFrisenBrooksFrisen, Abitheira, Brooks, DziurmanCarried 4-0
45:08Postpone approval of Sept. 2 minutes to the next meeting, with comments from the city and the board incorporatedNot identified on videoNot identified on videoAbitheira, Brooks, Dziurman, FrisenCarried 4-0
47:39Approve 2027 meeting dates, with July 7 moved to July 14 and Aug. 4 moved to Aug. 11FrisenNot identified on videoAbitheira, Brooks, Dziurman, FrisenCarried 4-0

The roll call at the start of the meeting recorded Abitheira, Brooks, Dziurman and Frisen as present.

Public comment timeline

Besides the petitioner, one person spoke, during the public hearing on the Burkoff variance. No letters or emails were received on the case, Abate said. No one spoke during general public comment.

TimeSpeakerComment
10:19Joshua Randolph, petitionerReason for the request. Bought the house about six weeks earlier; has a dog and plans to have children; wants a fence a person or animal cannot step over. Said most trees along Martinique and the rear lot line were dead and that the open aluminum fence would leave more visibility than the dense trees that stood there.
14:07Neighbor on Martinique DriveDriveway and sprinkler system. Asked whether a privacy fence would sit directly against the neighbor's driveway or be set back, citing a sprinkler head that faces the rear of the house on the east side, right off the driveway. Board members said only the first 40 feet of fence was before them. Abate said the fence installer must know where the property line is, and that a surveyor must establish it if there is any question.
26:36RandolphOffer to change the plan. Said the family would accept 4-foot aluminum for the whole fence and setting it a foot inside the property line, and would work out upkeep of that strip. Said the aim is to protect the family, not to hide it from view.
33:06RandolphAsked whether a denied request could be refiled. Abate said yes, if the new proposal differs from the one denied.
47:45General public commentNo one spoke.

Board member updates timeline

TimeSpeakerUpdate
1:23AbateCorrections to the Sept. 2 minutes. Three clarifications on the 5268 Hale sauna case, from a review of the meeting video (see above).
3:34BrooksAsked that the city attorney review any change to the minutes of an approval made after the hearing.
4:31FrisenAgreed with Brooks. Said the draft misstates his intent: he wanted an engineering opinion to support the applicant, not the building official.
17:30FrisenOn the fence: the open aluminum sections did not bother him much, citing a similar fence a block and a half away; opposed the 6-foot wood section.
23:58DziurmanSaid even a 4-foot open fence beside the neighbor's driveway and side-entry garage concerns him; would likely support it without the driveway.
25:09Board memberHad planned to ask for driveway sight triangles; after seeing the site and the area's other open fences, no longer had the visibility concern.
29:20AbitheiraReminded members the board is not supposed to negotiate with applicants, and said the chair can allow it.
29:47FrisenSaid the lot is not 40 feet wider than its neighbors but about 15 feet wider, so that without the setback area the yard is about the same size as theirs.
31:19BrooksAsked by the chair, said cutting back the corner was not needed because the fence is non-obscuring.
32:27Board memberTold the applicant only four members were present, that a 2-2 tie is a loss and that a postponement could run to January or February.
37:28CzarneckiSaid the September minutes being up for approval had not been clear beforehand, and that postponing them was no problem.
40:03DziurmanClarified his September point: many devices sold in the city are not UL-listed, so a denial on a UL rating alone lacked merit; everything else about the sauna met code.
41:35CzarneckiSaid minutes are brief summaries, building codes are outside the recording secretary's experience and the video records each speaker's intent.
42:06AbateSaid he wants the record to show the applicant did not meet all codes, contrary to what was said in September, and that he should have raised it at that meeting.
45:25MembersOpening statement. No comments had been emailed on the draft, and a reminder email had not gone out. Held to the next meeting.
45:57Members2027 dates. Conflicts named for July 7 and Aug. 4; both moved back a week.
47:56Board memberProcedure training. Asked whether the training with Clerk Dickson should be regular, citing the board's uncertainty about motions at this meeting.
49:04ParticipantOffered to share notes from the training session. A member later said the suggestion came from Abate.
51:34AbateAsked members to email comments on the draft opening statement by the next meeting.
52:13AbateConfirmed no December meeting.

What's next

  • Dec. 2: regular meeting canceled.
  • Next meeting: the first 2027 date was not stated at the meeting; a member said January or February. Members said a Feb. 3 meeting is on the schedule. Revised Sept. 2 minutes and the draft opening statement are expected back.
  • July 14 and Aug. 11, 2027: rescheduled summer meetings.

Comments are open below.

Comments
Loading...

Log in to comment.